Article menu
Imagine spending hours searching for jobs, tailoring your CV, writing a covering letter, answering screening questions and carefully completing a long application form. Then you wait patiently. A few days pass. Then a week. Perhaps a month. You may hear nothing at all. For many jobseekers, this isn’t an isolated experience, it’s a common reality. We take a look at why every job applicant deserves a response (even if you’re rejecting them) and how to ensure candidates will enjoy a positive experience.
What happened when I rejected 164 candidates
We were recently recruiting for a role at CharityJob, and I personally responded to all candidates who had applied. It wasn’t a grand gesture, and it certainly wasn’t a complicated exercise. I simply wanted to let people know that they hadn’t been selected and that we appreciated the time they had taken to apply.
What surprised me was the positive response I received from candidates I rejected. They were genuinely grateful that I had bothered to get back to them. Almost all took the time to thank me for responding, even though the news wasn’t what they had hoped for.
Think about that for a moment. I hadn’t offered them a job. I hadn’t invited them to an interview. I had simply told them they hadn’t been successful.
It was a powerful reminder of how low expectations have become. People are so accustomed to being ignored, that receiving a straightforward, courteous rejection felt like an unexpectedly positive experience.

Why you should respond to all applicants
Recruiters and employers sometimes forget just how difficult job hunting can be. Particularly in a competitive market, candidates can find themselves applying for dozens, if not hundreds of jobs without getting an interview, let alone an offer.
Every application takes time and effort. Candidates research organisations, adapt their CVs, write supporting statements and try to demonstrate why they are the right person for the role. They do this alongside their existing jobs, family commitments and everyday lives. For those who are unemployed, the process can be even more emotionally draining, especially when financial pressures are mounting. And when applications go unanswered, the impact goes beyond simple frustration.
Candidates begin to question themselves. Am I good enough? Is there something wrong with my CV? Am I ever going to find a job? Imagine putting yourself through that process week after week, sometimes month after month. Staying positive and motivated becomes incredibly difficult.
Empathy should be the norm
We regularly talk about the importance of kindness, empathy and treating people with respect in the workplace. Yet, when someone applies for a job, those basic courtesies can disappear.
Candidates should never be surprised when an employer treats them with basic consideration. If someone has taken the time to apply for a job with your organisation, the least you can do is let them know the outcome. You may not be able to give them the job, and you may not be able to offer detailed feedback. But you can give them an answer and treat people with respect.
For someone who has applied for their fiftieth, hundredth or two-hundredth job, that response can help them move on, maintain their momentum and keep looking for the right opportunity.

Being ignored can be worse than rejection
Of course nobody likes receiving a rejection. I’ve recruited enough people over the years to understand that you cannot appoint everyone who applies, however good their application might be. But there is a fundamental difference between being rejected and being ignored.
A rejection gives someone an answer. It allows them to draw a line under that application and concentrate on other opportunities. Silence leaves them in limbo, wondering whether the recruitment process is still under way, whether they might hear something eventually, or whether their application has disappeared into a black hole. And that uncertainty becomes exhausting.
Candidates don’t necessarily expect every employer to provide detailed feedback, particularly when hundreds of people have applied for a vacancy. But a simple email confirming the outcome? Surely that’s not too much to ask.
A poor candidate experience reflects negatively on you
There is every reason to get the candidate experience right. Candidates are not just names on an application form. They are potential future employees, donors and advocates.
A candidate who receives a courteous response may apply again in the future, recommend you to someone else or continue to support your work by donating. Someone who is ignored may walk away with a very different impression.
Negative experiences can also deter other potential candidates who have read reviews or heard word-of-mouth anecdotes. Research found that almost half of jobseekers (48%) read reviews on employee business review websites before starting the application process. Your employer brand isn’t just what you say about yourself on your careers page or social media. It’s what people experience first-hand when they interact with you.
There is a further point worth remembering: the person you reject today might be exactly the right candidate for a role you advertise next year. Treating people well keeps the door open.

Recruiters are busy, but so are candidates
I know and fully understand recruitment teams are under pressure. They may be managing multiple vacancies, dealing with hiring managers, reviewing hundreds of CVs and trying to keep recruitment moving. I don’t underestimate those demands.
But candidates are busy too. They invest their time in your organisation, often with no guarantee of even receiving an acknowledgement.
We need to stop treating communication with unsuccessful applicants as an optional extra that can be abandoned whenever workloads become heavy. It should be part of the recruitment process from the outset.
That doesn’t mean every applicant needs an individual explanation. It means setting realistic expectations, keeping candidates informed and ensuring that everyone who has applied receives an outcome once a decision has been made. Even a brief message can make a difference. To a candidate, it can be a welcome reminder that there is a human being on the other side of the process.
What candidates told us
The recruitment market is challenging for candidates right now. In an August 2026 CharityJob survey of 6,330 candidates, 75% of respondents revealed they are actively job hunting. But 19% of candidates revealed they had never heard back from jobs they had applied for, while a further 17% said they had waited for more than 2 months for a simple response. Unsurprisingly, this is tough for candidates to accept, with 21% admitting the lack of response makes them question whether they’re good enough, and 20% saying they felt it was disrespectful.
So, the next time you recruit, ask yourself one simple question: if I were the person waiting anxiously for an answer, how would I want to be treated? Then make sure your recruitment process reflects that answer.
How to respond to applicants
Technology makes it easier than ever to automate parts of the recruitment process. Our free Applicant Tracking System (ATS) helps charities organise applications, manage candidates through each stage of recruitment and communicate with applicants more effectively – including rejecting them for the role.
This ATS is free to all charities when they select ‘Apply with CV and/or cover letter’ as their preferred application method. It features a wealth of no-cost tools including the option to customise one of our template rejection emails and send it to unsuccessful applicants in bulk. Alternatively, you can use the system to create your own, specific to your charity.
By making it easier to manage the recruitment process, we want to help employers spend less time on admin, and more time ensuring candidates are treated with the consideration and respect they deserve.
Tags: attracting the right candidates, charity recruitment, charity sector recruitment, hiring process, job market


